Contextual Characteristics
The project emerged from earlier research exploring the experiences of marginalised groups in urban environments. Researchers involved in the SiBa (Safety in the Station District) project, funded by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research, had previously employed participatory methods such as interviews, guided walks, and group discussions to examine the experiences of people experiencing homelessness in Düsseldorf.
Over time, these projects shifted from viewing marginalised populations primarily as contributors to public insecurity towards understanding their own experiences of vulnerability and exclusion. Inspired by this change in perspective, an addiction researcher initiated a collaborative project with the University of Wuppertal focusing on Cologne’s Neumarkt area. Neumarkt is a public square in Cologne which is known as a meeting place for the open drug scene and where conflicts frequently arise.
The project also responded to growing public concern regarding the increasing visibility of crack cocaine use in Cologne. While public debates frequently highlight perceived threats posed by open drug scenes, the project sought to understand how people who use drugs themselves experience risk and insecurity in these public spaces.
Objectives
- Explore how people who use drugs perceive risk and insecurity in public spaces.
- Map locations considered threatening or significant by members of the open drug scene.
- Recognise drug users as experts in their own environment and lived experience.
- Provide an alternative narrative to dominant public discussions about open drug scenes.
- Increase empathy and understanding among professionals and the wider public.
Description
Open drug scenes are often characterised by health risks, social exclusion, violence, and insecurity. Yet research rarely examines how people who use drugs themselves perceive and navigate these environments.
As part of a broader series of social space explorations, researchers mapped the drug scene around Cologne’s Neumarkt using a participatory auto-photography approach. Seven individuals recruited through local drug consumption facilities and outreach addiction services received disposable cameras and were asked to photograph locations that held particular significance for them. The participants subsequently discussed the images in interviews, enabling researchers to better understand their perceptions, routines, fears, and coping strategies.
The project adopted a lifeworld-oriented perspective, treating participants as experts on their own environment. By documenting their experiences through photographs and personal narratives, the study aimed to reconstruct everyday realities within the open drug scene and reveal perspectives often absent from public debates.
The photographs and interview excerpts were later incorporated into a mobile exhibition travelling across Germany, allowing broader audiences to engage with the experiences of people who use drugs.
Stakeholders Involved
- University of Wuppertal
- Addiction researchers
- Drug users participating in the study
- Cologne Public Health Department
- Drug consumption room services
- Outreach addiction support services
- Exhibition organisers and participating institutions
- German AIDS Service Organisation (Deutsche AIDS-Hilfe)
- Security and social work professionals engaging with the project’s findings
Social Innovation & Methodology
The project employed a participatory research methodology centred on auto-photography, a method that enables participants to document and interpret their own environments through photography.
Rather than being studied solely as subjects of research, participants actively contributed to knowledge production by identifying and photographing locations they considered relevant. Follow-up interviews allowed participants to explain the meaning of these places and discuss how they experienced safety, insecurity, violence, exclusion, and everyday life within the drug scene.
This bottom-up approach sought to challenge conventional security research perspectives, which often focus on how marginalised groups are perceived by others. Instead, the project prioritised the experiences of people who use drugs and aimed to bring their voices into public discussions about urban security and public space.
The resulting photographs and narratives were subsequently shared through exhibitions designed to stimulate dialogue and encourage a better understanding of the participants’ lived realities.
Innovative Elements
Changing the Security Narrative
The project reframed discussions about security in public spaces by shifting attention from how drug users are perceived by others to how they themselves experience insecurity. This represents an important departure from traditional approaches that often portray marginalised groups primarily as sources of disorder.
Participatory Knowledge Production
By treating people who use drugs as experts in their own environment, the project challenged conventional researcher-participant hierarchies and enabled knowledge creation from lived experience.
Giving Voice to Marginalised Groups
Participants were involved not only in data collection but also in public dissemination activities, including exhibitions displaying their photographs and perspectives. This helped make otherwise marginalised experiences visible to broader audiences.
Interdisciplinary Innovation
The collaboration between security researchers and addiction researchers generated new perspectives and demonstrated the benefits of interdisciplinary approaches to urban security and public space research.
Outcomes and Impact
Increased Public Awareness
The travelling exhibition has helped raise awareness of the experiences and vulnerabilities of people who use drugs, encouraging audiences to reconsider common assumptions about open drug scenes.
New Insights into Perceived Insecurity
The project revealed several important findings:
- Participants were highly aware of how the wider public perceived them.
- Locations feared by drug users often overlapped with places viewed as unsafe by the general population.
- Their presence in these areas was frequently driven by a lack of alternatives rather than personal choice.
- Drug users experienced many of the same environmental concerns as other citizens, such as darkness, litter, and neglect.
- Participants also reported frequent exposure to violence and aggression, including attacks by passersby.
- Security personnel were often perceived not as sources of protection but as additional sources of anxiety.
Wider Dissemination
For International Remembrance Day for People Who Died from Drug Use in July 2025, posters based on the project were distributed nationwide through the German AIDS Service Organisation, extending the project’s reach to numerous institutions throughout Germany.
External Recognition
The initiative was nominated for the Betty Ford Clinics’ Destigmatisation Award, recognising its contribution to reducing stigma surrounding substance use disorders.
Lessons Learned
- Participatory methods can successfully engage highly marginalised groups when adapted to their realities.
- Practical incentives are often necessary to support participation.
- Auto-photography offers flexibility because participants can document their experiences independently and at their own pace.
- Researchers should expect logistical challenges, including the loss or non-return of equipment.
- Many participants expressed a strong desire to challenge stereotypes and present a more nuanced account of their lives.
- Interdisciplinary collaboration can produce valuable new perspectives on complex social issues.
- Approaches developed in one research field can often be successfully adapted to another.
- Public willingness to engage with difficult social issues may be greater than anticipated when stories are communicated through personal experiences.
Limitations
- The project did not receive dedicated external funding and relied largely on institutional resources and researchers’ time.
- Working with individuals experiencing substance use disorders presented challenges due to the instability and pressures associated with addiction.
- Some research materials, including disposable cameras, were not returned.
- The small number of participants limits the generalisability of findings.
Sustainability
The project’s exhibition materials continue to be used in different locations across Germany, ensuring that its central message remains visible beyond the research phase.
The findings have also sparked discussions among public institutions, including police organisations, regarding opportunities to better understand the lived realities of people who use drugs and to promote more empathetic forms of engagement.
By creating reusable exhibition materials and publicly accessible visual content, the project has established a sustainable mechanism for continuing dialogue on urban security, vulnerability, stigma, and inclusion.
Source Material
- Interview with project representatives conducted within the CO-SECUR project
- News article:
https://www.spiegel.de/panorama/koeln-einblick-in-die-drogenszene-am-neumarkt-a-6b10505f-ad98-456a-9683-fdb25e0aea1a?giftToken=c99d1ac3-b8e2-4d6c-9a59-28fcca5f4813