S4AllCities – Protection of crowds during massive gatherings for festivities in the city centre and metro station

Every festival, parade or big city gathering brings the same challenge: how to keep a dense crowd safe without making people feel watched, controlled, or unwelcome in their own public space. In Bilbao, the European project S4AllCities piloted a set of technologies at the city’s metro station and surrounding streets to protect crowds during mass gatherings, while trying to answer that harder question directly – surveying citizens across Spain, Greece and the Czech Republic on how useful, and how intrusive, they actually found these tools to be.

Contextual Characteristics

The pilot took place in an urban setting in Bilbao, Spain, focused on the city centre and its metro station during periods of mass gathering for local festivities.

Objectives

  • Improve the system’s development by using expert criteria.
  • Evaluate the usefulness and level of acceptance of the demonstrated features through questionnaires and discussion sessions.
  • Assess system performance metrics for both individual functionalities and the comprehensive system.

Description

The Bilbao pilot of the S4AllCities European project focused on testing innovative solutions for crowd protection during mass gatherings in the city centre, particularly at the metro station and surrounding areas. The pilot leveraged advanced technologies to address the safety and security of public spaces during high-density events, run in October 2022 by a consortium including Ertzaintza, BilbaoTIK, the Hellenic Police, BEIA, SINTEF and the Municipality of Bilbao.

Stakeholders Involved

  • Smart city operators
  • First responders
  • Law enforcement agencies
  • Ertzaintza (autonomous police of the Basque Country)
  • BilbaoTIK
  • Hellenic Police
  • BEIA
  • SINTEF
  • Municipality of Bilbao

Social Innovation & Methodology

S4AllCities built several social innovation elements into its approach. A participatory and inclusive strategy engaged stakeholders, including citizens, in evaluating and understanding the societal impacts of the technologies being tested. Public engagement and trust-building were central to validation actions carried out in Spain, Greece and the Czech Republic, where the usefulness and intrusiveness of the security technologies were specifically assessed.

The project also placed emphasis on localised pilot testing – as in Bilbao, focused on mass gatherings – ensuring that the solutions developed were tailored to specific urban contexts, which helped strengthen their relevance and acceptance. At the same time, the project directly tackled the ethical challenge of deploying surveillance technologies by engaging citizens and taking their privacy concerns into account, a key element of socially responsible innovation.

Innovative Elements

  • Participatory technology assessment: rather than testing technologies in isolation, S4AllCities built citizen and stakeholder evaluation directly into its methodology, using a three-round assessment strategy to gather transparent, consensus-driven insight into societal impact.
  • Cross-country societal impact research: running the same assessment across Spain, Greece and the Czech Republic allowed the project to compare acceptance and concerns across different national contexts.
  • Gender-sensitive analysis: the project explicitly examined how gender shaped attitudes toward security technologies, treating this as a design consideration rather than an afterthought.
  • Ethics-by-design approach to surveillance: privacy and intrusiveness concerns were treated as central variables to be measured and addressed, rather than side effects to be managed after deployment.

Technology Used

While the specific technical architecture tested in the Bilbao pilot is not fully documented in the available material, the pilot’s overall aim was to demonstrate crowd-protection technologies suited to mass gatherings in dense urban settings such as a metro station, evaluated through structured questionnaires, discussion sessions and system performance metrics covering both individual functionalities and the system as a whole.

Outcomes and Impact

  • Societal impact: the project’s societal effects were assessed through a participatory, scientific approach, using a three-round assessment that provided transparency and consensus-driven insight. Positive impacts identified included reduced risks, improved citizen cooperation, better anticipation and decision-making by security stakeholders, and deterrence of hostile actions. At the same time, the assessment flagged unintended effects worth watching, such as over-reliance on technology and concerns about behavioural monitoring.
  • Public acceptance: a survey conducted across Spain, Greece and the Czech Republic found that 77.5% of respondents considered the technology useful, while 55.7% viewed it as intrusive. Support for implementation stood at 50.4%, with 27.9% hesitant and 21.7% sceptical. Acceptance varied with gender, age, political views and country, shaped by respondents’ trust, perceived effectiveness and sense of intrusiveness.
  • Gender relevance: gender differences, subtle in some respects, proved significant in others – women showed greater acceptance of security technologies, higher trust in institutions, and a stronger sense of their effectiveness compared with men, while both genders shared similar concerns about privacy and intrusiveness. These findings underline the importance of incorporating gender perspectives into the design and implementation of counterterrorism technologies.

Lessons Learned

  • Participatory, multi-round assessment strategies can provide transparent, consensus-driven insight into how citizens actually experience new security technologies, rather than assuming acceptance.
  • Usefulness and intrusiveness are not opposites that cancel each other out: a majority of citizens can find a technology useful while a majority also finds it intrusive, and both perceptions need to be addressed on their own terms.
  • Gender, age, political views and national context all shape acceptance of security technologies and should be treated as design considerations rather than statistical footnotes.
  • Trust, effectiveness and perceived intrusiveness are the three main levers shaping public opinion, and future projects should design communication and safeguards around all three.

Limitations

  • Hesitation and scepticism among nearly half of surveyed citizens highlight the ongoing challenge of ensuring widespread societal acceptance of security technologies of this kind.

Sustainability

No direct information on the sustainability of the Bilbao pilot’s outcomes was found, but some insight can be drawn from the S4AllCities project’s own societal impact report. The project’s use of participatory methods – a three-round assessment strategy and cross-country surveys – supports long-term social acceptance by incorporating diverse perspectives and working toward consensus.

While most citizens surveyed (77.5%) found the technology useful, the level of concern about intrusiveness (55.7%) and hesitance (27.9%) point to a continued need for engagement and public education to address concerns about surveillance and privacy. Addressing perceptions of intrusiveness and strengthening privacy safeguards will be critical for maintaining public trust over time, and the project’s findings on public and gender differences offer a foundation for more equitable deployment in the future.

Source Material